Total of 41 complaints made about Newcastle-under-Lyme councillors over past 13 months
By Phil Corrigan - Local Democracy Reporter 17th Nov 2026
More than 40 formal complaints have been made about elected members at a borough council over the past 13 months, a new report shows.
Newcastle-under-Lyme Borough Council received a total of 41 member code of conduct complaints between the start of October 2025 and the end of October 2026.
But none of them have so far resulted in a councillor being formally sanctioned for breaching the code.
Three-quarters of the complaints – 31 – were dismissed at the initial stage after no breach was identified, with one more being dismissed after an investigation, and one being withdrawn.
Six complaints were dealt with through an 'informal resolution', and two cases remain open.
The latest complaints statistics were reported to members of the council's audit and standards committee.
Monitoring officer Olwen Brown told the committee that most of the complaints related to alleged misuse of position or information (19 complaints) or online behaviour (12 complaints), with only three relating to bullying or harassment.
Ms Brown said: "Online breaches of the code of conduct are causing a lot of issues at the moment.
"Members will be aware of this, and I know some of you will have been subject to online matters as well, from members of the public, from parish and town councillors, and from members of this authority.
"There have been very few complaints about bullying and harassment, which is a relief I think."
Councillor Simon Tagg noted that there had been a sharp rise in complaints over the summer, with 10 received in August alone.
He said: "It may have been the balmy summer, but we did have a spike, with 10 complaints in August, which is double the previous highest monthly total.
"What is the reason for that, other than people spending very hot nights on social media and frayed tempers, perhaps?"
Ms Brown suggested that the local elections in May were key factors behind the increase, with the borough council, along with town and parish councils, seeing an influx of new members, who are 'not necessarily used to the code of conduct regime and how it operates'.
Councillor Jeremy Lefroy questioned why so many complaints were being dismissed at the initial stage.
He said: "One view could be that we have an awful lot of unwarranted complaints coming in, which is taking up time.
"But a cynical, outsider's view could be that the code is not really working, because you can make a complaint and nothing happens. It is a very delicate balance to strike."
Ms Brown told the committee that the code only applies when a councillor is acting in their capacity as an elected member, and in some cases it is immediately clear that the code does not apply.
She added: "We do look at them very carefully because if someone has gone to the effort of making a complaint, it deserves to be taken seriously. But we have to be fair to all parties. So it is important to look at that first test.
"When a complaint is dismissed, it doesn't necessarily mean that it wasn't felt genuinely, but they may well have been mistaken."
Since the Localism Act 2011, local authorities rather than national bodies have been responsible for dealing with most code of conduct complaints.
The report states that the act also 'reduced very significantly' the available sanctions for breaches, with evidence suggesting that this has resulted in rising levels of 'unacceptable behaviour'.
The Society of Local Authority Chief Executives recently produced a report calling the current system 'broken and not fit-for-purpose' and recommending a raft of changes.
Last year the government said there would be a move towards a revised standards regime with strengthened sanctions, but it is unclear when this will happen.
CHECK OUT OUR FREE NEWSLETTER!
5 TOP STORIES EVERY FRIDAY!
Click here to sign up: stoke newsletter
Share: